Nice sigs, but both of them are a bit plain.. just render and text. I like the bubble effect on the first, but it doesn't really fit the sig.. Also, the text could use some more work, maybe different font. Nice render, but it is exactly the same color as the background, which kinda takes out the life of the render.. Same here about the text. Your in the right way mate
flux22 1st: 7/10(Not too appealing to me.. Text need some work) 2nd: 7.5/10(Text need work.. again..)