1st-text needs more work 9/10 2nd-the right side seems boring 8.5/10 3rd-dont like the stroke of the text 9/10
The popout part doesnt work. Get rid of the pop out render, and brush the bg over there it will look better. Text i crap, the text quality looks bad and the glow is worse 3/10
Top, i saw the post of b4 and after and its a major improvement. 8/10 Good improvement but still not the best sig Bottom, too much brightness. Text needs a little work, im not really feeling t 5/10
8/10 for all of them, your renders tend to stick out of the sigs tho but your backgrounds pwn text is cool too and yeah my second sig is just an edited version of a splash i made it looks better as a splash but i g2 have her in my sig does that look better?
I really like the first one. The clash between the dark and light is awesome, and the background colors enhance the image. The one thing I dislike is the type placement, its very random. I enjoy the colors and glowing feel, but I don't like images directly in the middle of artwork, it ruin it for me. The little slash and text look great. I don't really care for the third one much.