The Star wars one gets a 8/10, I can barely read General. The chick sig gets a 7/10, the render needs to be blended.
1st 9.5/10 nice colors 2nd 9/10 loving the effects, seems like shes popping out of some rose bush. 3rd 6/10 don't like the background, some of the pixel strtch is obviously apperent.
1st and 2nd, Vnice nothing to say (just one thing, why does it seem like there are cracks in the fire in the 2nd sig?) 9/10 overall
I like it, its different, text could use a little bit of work and i think theres too much black on the bottom - 7.5/10
um i like it, odnt like the black and white them, but the text is nice and simple good background, 7/10
1st-blend the render and the text is hard to read 7.5/10 2n-i like it but there are some gray spots 9/10
Top, the bg colors need to be a little more yellow, the rest is good. 8/10 Bottom, not feeling the colors or text, doesnt really flow 6/10
1st-great work 9/10 2nd-blend the render and add some more blue to go with the render 8/10 3rd-render is too dark 9/10 4th-dont like the text 9/10