Rate The Sig Above You ..

1st- color is monotone..brushing is alright
2nd- its alright i guess, well its an advertisement banner

 

awesome very very nice 10/10 cant find anything wrong

 

nice

1-9/10
2-9/10
3-9/10
4-10/10

 

nice sigs 9/10 9/10 8/10 7/10

 

9/10

like it, nice render but lacks a border

my sigs are not entrys because i am a n00b in the GFX world but you can rate them if you want

 

@auron 2k5

not bad but work on ur text bg an render blendin my tip is jus dodge and smudge tool and polygonnal lasso also look up some tuts 6.5/10

 

@Psychodesignz

thanks for the constructive critism

have only been using photoshop for about a week so am still very new to the GFX world but am currently looking for bruches and fonts to use and have 1000's of images to render but haven't yet got the skill to make the images look good with the backgrounds,

TUT are helpful cuz they tell me how to do some of the things that i do not yet know how to do do am looking for some decent TUT's aswell,

anyway

10/10 for your sigs,
I really like the top one

 

first 6/10 not bad
second 4/10, bad.. i miss a border... and the BG is so empty

 

8/10 nice render blended well...just not a fan of the bg

 

9/10 on all
they're very good can't find
anything wrong with them`

 

9/10

7/10

7/10

8/10

 

liddotidus-7/10, dont like the text, and if i rember the scan lines were above the render,

 

8/10 i like it,

 

1. 8/10 great blending and layout
2. 7/10 i didnt like it as much too wide a variety of scan lines were used and the txt didnt stand out as much but gj.

 

pretty good banners.

7/10