Rate The Sig Above You ..

8/10 a bit dark =/

 

urg,

This one isn't good but i do realize you are pretty new to Gfx so not bad for a beginner.

Keep working

(not giving a number, too mean)

 

strange hard grunge style. Dont see it much.

Your text could use some work, but i know how hard it is to find good text for sigs. The brushing and colors seem good, the text totally kills the first one, the white on the left edge may do that also.

Overall: voth 8/10

 

1st 9/10 - i like colours
2nd 7/10 - I don't know why but I don't like it

 

That is wicked it looks like a CSS sig (terroist) if it is 9/10 best one if seen

 

the first and the third are ok, don't really like the pics, but the second :wub: , it's a penguin :wub:
let's say 8/10 for the first and the third and 9,5/10

 

Nice colours, but the brushing on the left covers too much of the lake, IMO. Still like it overall. 8.5/10

 

1st - 9/10 - i like movie in sigs i like colours
2nd - 6/10 i really dont like render and text :/ colours are bad too :/

 

10/10 i love everything

 

That's pretty awesome. 9.8/10

 

1st - 6/10
2nd - 5/10

nothing special

 

EDIT + Slayer - 8/10 I really like that sig.

 

1st 7/10

2nd 6/10

my personal opinion about the way you have done it

 

8/10. Like the effect.

 

Lol , pretty funny ... not really nice but its rpetty funny made 8/10