Top, needs more color, try to get the bg to match the render color, not the other way around. 7/10 Bottom, I see a motion blur.
Very Very Nice...the left hand side (from my view) is very nice not something I have seen in any other sigs...the right hand side (from my view lol) looks quite cool....the text isn't that good but I think everything else looks perfect so 9/10
First one is just monotone, and the text is blah..6/10 I don't like popouts at all, so I'm not gonna rate the 2nd one.
the first one is good but it would be nice if the render was blended alittle bit. the secound one is kind of hard to tell whats going on but that one is also pretty good
6/10 because i dont like grunge or the render 8.5/10 excellent colors and i dont mind the grundge on this one. not a fan of the white dodged edges
The bg looks a little plain but theres something really cool looking about it and the render and the text lok great 7/10 Second the bgi is way to plain but the render and text look fine 6/10