Do They Realy Need To Be Perfect?

Do You Guys think that renders should realy be cut to perfection?
I personaly thing No since the edges get cut off when they are
being blended so some one would realy only need a well cut render
if they dident know how to blend and if they dont they will soon learn
since of the tuts on this site. Post you comments i just wanna know
what people think

 

No, they can be way from perfect to me! Blending those renders is easy, maybe even easier then a perfect cut-out render

Bratzer

 

I'd say no and yes. Some must be a yes to look very good^^ But some no as they add a better effect to what your doing =P

 

Imo they have to be perfect, cus my blending sux

 

no way do they!

my cuts are not perfect, and i dont care, were all learning. and blending them is easy. so...

 

i saw a tut where someone didnt even render (just bg) he just used the eraser and the sig came out nice

 

That comes out nice if the bg is good but i dont feel right doing it since it is like ripping the whole bg

 

i dont think so. my renders r crap. i dont do them very well and yet when u put them in a sig they turn out really nice

 

i stopped using renders ages ago , just use the normal picture and blend in what you want.

 

i use em still....but yes..what ir u doa Vector BG...its noticable....

 

No perfect but good enough, once i blended it you cant notice it. As for vectors i dont do them so doesnt really bother me.

 

usually i'll find a awsome pic and do a bad job rendering it and they just blend it nicely and it'll come out good

but lately i havent been using renders much

 

i dont think they do depends what u want it for pop out sigs yea perfect cuts needed but for blending na they dont need to b perfect

 

perfect. i never blend the usual way, i dont fade out edges. thats why i want them really perfect!

 

perfect renders > better quality in sigs but meh I don't think it makes such a big differents so no =D