I like the animations on both of the images. I really like the Zalzame siggy better than the op one though. I would rate the top 8/10 and the bottom 10/10
new 9.5/10... i like the render, second font is bad... change it for current, its plain, nice brushing, move batman over to right more 7/10
First... pure brushing... and it works. <_< 8/10. Second... er... 6/10. Dunno if it's meant to be that way.
1st one, not bad, could have picked a better render, the brushing is good, but the text needs a little working on. 7/10. 2nd one, same with the text, but nice multicoloring. Also, the pixel text is a little hard to see. 7.5/10.
snakebite: 1st is original 8/10 I don't really like 2nd but its creative to use those lines when everyone doesn't so 7/10
Rating TheProphet Text might be a little too blurred. Sig's too big imo, so there's quite a bit of plain spaces around. quite decent overall tho 7.5/10
7.5/10. What really ruined it for me was the text. Umm besides that I don't like the motion blur feel*... Edit: That was for The Prophet