Your first sig is alright but your second sig is well done but sorta plain the render blends well and the font is well placed 8/10.
a bit to much blurred, and i can stil see the render. but its a nice render. 7.2/10 second is also nice, but im not a fan of the blue, or the render. 6.9/10
I like the firsts one grung feel. Good set of colors, overall really good sig. 8/10 Then Second one I love. Awesome job on it. 9/10
A bit weird, I don't really like it. 6,5/10. @ Hell Knight I posted the Render in the Render subforum
Im not likin the effect you have going on over it all, both are basically the same, not feelin it, sorry