9/10 for the vector one, scanlines don't look right on it. But the rest is really good. nice style to it, and coloring goes well. The red one 8/10 again the scanilnes kill it, not as badly this time. I just don't think they fit either sig.
You should show the render more in the first one, and put more work on the text to the left 7/10 Overall, great God of War sig, no problem with it 8/10