the first one i like. the colors match the render and so on... 8/10 i don't like number 2. not that mutch into pink. 5/10
5.5/10 No real blending, I'm not feeling the connection at all. Link is just there, lying flat. Sig is a bit too flat as well, and there's just no style, IMHO.
6/10 You should learn not to think that only you know what a good sig is. Giving a 5/10 without any reason...?
I like it, really nice colours, nice renders, not a very good animation IMO But it think its really nice 8,5/10
I like it very much! to nad one brush got a bit over the render, and the text is weird IMO but still, 9/10