i do it for the enjoyment.. people that ask creds for making somebody sigs are stupid and have no clue about the reasons for making sigs.
I don't make sigs for the general public anymore, but when I did, I did it for the simple fact that it was enjoyable. Selling sigs for credits is fine, its kids being kids, but if someone is dumb enough to pay money for someone to take an artists picture and put it on another artists brushes, than thats just stupid, and not to mention illegal.
I do myn for enjoyment. Come check out my free sig shop if anyone wants too, pinned in the marketplace, 22 sigs for free or so..
So, we're gotten a large amount of people who do it for the fun of it/for free, yet I see that 11 or so people said yes to the question... hmm, I wonder why they didn't reply here...
i think making sigs for a profit is kinda stupid but i think that you should have some sort of thing to make your forums unique but thats just me i vote no you should not charge