they both look nice would take the sqaure fill off the first think it would look better that way,9/10 for both
they are both a little too plain... its like a cd4 render and then another render... next time add more brushng... both get a 6/10
take away the stroke, and the spidey-stock looks a little 'flat' compared to the rest of the sig. For example. The text saying "Spiderman" looks like its all the way in the back, and that the stock is a piece of cardboard you would find in comic stores, 8/10