i somewhat agree with you bth the C&C isnt terrible but the old game renders community i feel were better artists now a lot of the C&C comes from newbs but luckly this thread got some good artists's C&C
you dont have to be a good artist to give good C&C. critique and designing are two different things. Ive seen real good artists who give terrible C&C...
I disagree. While you dont have to be amazingly good at making sigs to give good C&C, you actually have to know what you're talking about. And most of the people who give C&C these days barely understand what a good sig looks like.
Yeah but it works both ways. a lot of art critics in the world are terrible artists, but they know what makes a good piece. sigs are a type of art, and no ones comments should just be dismissed because they struggle with making sigs themself. Its obvious when something is genuine cnc, and just spam. I think anyone who has taken the time to write some proper criticism should have their comments taken into account, and not disregarded because theyre a "noob".
i Agree with both you of i guess i Should of made it more clear. Tho good artists don't always give the best C&C but they understand how to use lighting,blending,contrast etc. and people that arnt great artists can give amazing advise but if there own work doesn't represent what they speak of it can often make it known that they don't fully understand what they are talking about or have yet to have the experience enough to give you a very in depth C&C.
so these arnt c4d right? Artist link: http://browse.deviantart.com/digitalart/3d/?q=c4d&order=9&offset=48#/d20ny6s Artist link: http://chexm1x.deviantart.com/art/Firestarter-155732986 Artist link: http://browse.deviantart.com/digitalart/3d/?q=c4d&order=9&offset=24&offset=72#/d2kvqdu