I really like the second one. It has good colours and depth. The effects may be overcrowding the render. I especially like your typography in the second one. The boarder works for it too. The first is the complete opposite in the first part. I don't see very much depth, and the colours just seem to be there. The lighting doesn't really add anything. I still love the typography
Thank you for your C&C. I've been really trying to improve the typography in my signatures as of late. [I was a text in the corner guy before just recently] I"ll work on the depth in the first sig. I always seem to have that problem when i smudge in sigs.
I like the first one. The second one is nice, I just think it's missing something that I can't figure out...