Rate My Outcome

Sorry if this is the wrong section

Before:


After:

 

For some reason, I don't really like the brown spot in the middle. I like the grungy feel of it but I think that you can do more to it to have that feeling explode a little more. Overall, it feels incomplete to me.

 

Its good besides the tree area is blanked and dosn't have those white lines. It really stands out

 

I'll see what else I can do to it, thanks for your feedback.

 

i dont like the coffee stain, it might look better if it was massive and cropped.
burn the edges?

 

If the stain was the Omen symbol from GOW2, it'd be win.

 

Maybe tearing around the edges, or maybe burning as mentioned above. The brown stain is a little unrealistic looking... it seems to pop-out strangely. Not sure what it is with that.

Maybe more of a crease around the (fold area?) that line in the right-ish section of the picture.

You asked for a rating?

Banana out of space-time continuum. <---------- ratings are arbitrary.