5/10 for first sig. Sorry but it looks like you took a photo and simply put a render on it. Render doesn't blend with pic at all 9/10 for 2nd because it looks pretty nice and render goes well with it.
4/10, sorry but i really dont like it, looks plain and the text isnt good either, just not very interesting to look at in general, sorry to say.. i like the colors and the idea behind it though
In my eyes i think it's really cool, the only thing i don't rly like is the border in the sig and well i think the white stripe doesn't really fit 7-8/10
i like the colour. but i really dont understand what im looking at so it really seems like my eyes focus on the text 6/10
Well the concept is great and everything comes together nicely. The only thing I dislike is the lettering 8.5/10
7/10 its only like the 30th one of those I've seen =_= but you did it pretty well, its appealing to look at
8/10, I love the render and the effects, I just think that the "cloud" text and the bold white bar was out of place though its very forgivable