I like the way the red really just pops out at you, it's a very nice effect . Only thing that kind of throws me off is the blending around her hair (particularly on the left), it just looks a little odd. Otherwise great job
Yes, V3 is better but the area that I thought didn't look right was on the left. Here, I circled the area I'm talking about so you can see. Most of the hair on the right is dark, but then towards the left it looks like it gets blended into something and is lighter and that's what threw me off
<strike>ya, if u look @ the original the hair is like that, bad photo im guessing</strike> i believe it's fixed