Sotw?

1 or 2 is better for SOTW? or neither? general C&C please too

1



2



EDIT: new version! thanks for the advice everyone

3

 

2 by far the first feels too flat and boring. I generally like b&w better too, but in this case the colored version is much better. I love it actually, though ya kinda need some naked chicks somewhere in there to spice it up. but i guess it'll do as is

but yeah, go with 2.

 

k, i think im the first enrty? maybe.

the theme is scenery, so we arent supposed to have any exciting small focal points, its supposed to be about the whole sig

 

i was joking about the naked chicks. jeez.

the first is left boring, plain and simple. the 2nd sort of gives the viewer a purpose to stop and look, rather than just being another entry to browse by.

 

gotchya.

thanks for the input

 

anyone else?

is it too bright?

too contrasted?

im starting to think i should fix the lighting.

 

i like the second i feel something about it... nice work m8!

 

I like the 2nd better. Don't know what is it, but it pulls my attention. Nice to see you have your own style.

 

Too much FX mate, seems kinda plain tho .

 

its scenery / landscape ---- its supposed to look plain -- i think

v2. yep !
although the text is hard to read and the middle is too bright ... or my monitor is too bright . stupid DotA with your dark forests ...... making me adjust my monitor

 

Definitely v2. Some parts seem over-sharpened. But I like this one. Very unique.

 

thanks guys, i think ill adjust it and make it not-so-bright.

i still have time before SOTW entries are closed

 

numba 2 and it looks a bit over sharpened

 

v2 for sure, the lighting is the only thing that seems awkward

p.s. dota ftw