1st: 9/10 - Why does it just say 'ell'? EDIT: Oh. I didn't notice the H behind it. 2nd: 8.5/10 Rate this stupid thing.
Text needs to be changed, and the overall sig is too long for the small render that's in it. Background could use work, the little bright patches look out of place. 6/10
Between the two, it's a good contrast. By them selves, the top one feels a bit bright, the bottom one a bit dark. Of course this is purely personal preference there. 8.0/10 8.5/10
dump that whored alien league font otherwise good sig a little plain i hate sigs with no pic but thats just me 7.5/10
Left: It's hard to make out the render and the text is a little too subtle. The background is ok but a little crowded. And I don't like vertical sigs. 7/10 Right: Much better. The render is nicely blended and the text looks great. The background too looks really good. 9/10