V2. V1 is way monotone and the text is distracting. V2, however, it works nicely. Work on your depth and blending of the render though. Lighting is pretty good though. Could be better. Flow is unclear. Is it radial flow? ^_^
Nice flow - i like radial flows because it gives good focus on the render.. yeah black and white is good.. shows the lighting better text is good too ! i suck with text --- T_T
really really monotone here. its a little too basic and needs more of everything. composition, depth, and flow. try adding more FX and work on text a little, it could be a bit better. :]
Monotone like everyone else has said, try not to tilt your text if you can help it ^_^ B&W is nice though, work on depth <3