My New Sig

Hey guys,

i made this sig, i know it needs alot of work, but i believe its an improvement for me and i would like some feedback on what i can do to make this better

v1

v2


thats my image, its empty on the right side, i'm not sure what to put there, i was thinking maybe like a scenery image and blend it with the background,
also i was wondering what do you guys think about the text and the blending on the render, i have been having some issues with the text on my other sigs,


Thanks for all your help


**Edit**
Added V2

 

what i would say is to not have ur sig be 3 tones of the same color. try to use colors from the render in a background
so ull have a 2/3 color themed peice. "monotonous" is a word ull see if you make sigs like this because they are
just one color. i'm very impressed because you managed to create good depth just by blending. good job!
=]

 

ok ill keep that in mind for my next sig,

Thanks for the feedback, also what do you think about the right side of it? is it to plain or is it fine?

 

well depending on the style of sig. you could put some other abstract stuff in there.. or you could use the burn/dodge tools
if you wanted to make it look like a grunge sig. for this style of sig it seems to me like there should be trees or something
for her to be guarding or something

 

When you say use the burn and dodge, like what do you mean, were should i dodge and burn??? like should i do as a big brush to make it look like its fading to dark or light or should i do small brush to make details??

Thanks again for the feedback

 

Ok my opinion, I like it. First look at it I think carved stone. Idk if you meant it that way but, the texture of the bg lead me to think that way. The color flows together nicely. Size I would say 10px off h&w. Then again I'm not crazy about large sigs. Idk what to say other then I like it.

 

everything needs work.
color.
overblended.
plain bg.
no fx.
no depth.
monotone color again.
no depth all lighting is the same
dull.
.................

 

whats size do you recomend i use for sigs,

that sig was 370 120

 

Size should depend sig to sig.

 

I suggest that you don't use such big size. I use 350x125.

 

Text needs work. Colours are very monotone. Look at a few tutorials, get the feel of your render, and try to envision a final product. These are all things that helped me.

 

dood this doesn't help anyone.
by the look of the sig you can tell he is no ps expert *no offense*
but maybe a tip or a hint on how to fix any of those things... or a link to a tut lol
kinda harsh on a beginner.

 

thanks for the advice guys, as for that sig, yes it is monotone, i did use a filter to make it like that. for my next sig ill try and improve the size,color and then the background

thank you guys for all the feedback