They are all really bland and colorless. If they have color it's not standing out enough and very monotone. The effects are lame and concept-less, as well as low quality and they hurt the feel. None of your stocks are great stocks, and your text work needs a lot of practice. All the tags your posted are boring and have no wow factor, no actual concept, and not enough visual interest. I think you should read some tutorials. Sorry man.
What's to be sorry about? I know, I need to work on coloring more. Ur the only one who actually sees that in my tags as I do. Also, I do need to work on text, know any good text tuts? Why would you be sorry? I appreciate the advice.
I'm sorry that you keep getting pointless critisism from half of the gamerender's members. It's stupid. Saying, "ohh nice sig gj i like." Isn't gonna get anyone better. Infact, worse. And no one's sigs are perfect, which means theres always room for improvement, which means POST SOME LEVEL-MINDED CRTISISM FOR ONCE. Okay I'm done ranting. Just check out the tuts forum, there are soooo many tutorials. Text usually comes from creativity and sig concept. And mostly just captioning. If I made a Final Fantasy sig I wouldn't caption it with, FROM THE DEPTHS OF HELL, because unless it is really an evil looking sig, it doesn't really fit. I think it's a matter of looking at a lot of really good sigs, stealing their ideas until you find your own, and then stick with that and then you can morph it into your own perspective.
Overall, not that bad. But. what I see in multiple tags, is there very messy, and lack clean depth and flow. Try not making your tags so splashy, if that makes sense . Try making the tag flow to the focal point of the tag so your eyes arn't jumping everywhere, confused. Example: I don't really know whats going on!?!?!?!? I Hope I Helped PS: I like your last posted tag in here, but its over sharpened imo.
Yeah, I noticed that a lot of my tags don't really have flow a lot of the time. Been trying to work on that. I also think the last one is a bit over-sharpened. Maybe add a v2 some time later.