Making Final Touches On A Tag--need Opinions

Ive got this pretty much where i want it i just dont know how i like the border... heres where you come in. Which is better?



or

 

I recommend the first one, it's much better but maybe you could go for the negatives border...

You know a negative film strip and they have those edges? They'd look killer as a border.

 

v1.

Darken it a bit, and like Mort said, negative border. :]

 

I tried the negative thing and didnt really like it, it just looked terribly out of place.

 

Negative border, but then erase over it with a low opacity brush, or lower the opacity of the layer.

and then darken the siggy.
haha

You can see i use alot of erasing xD

 

I darkened it and it looked alot better but i tried the negative with lowering the opacity and i just dont think it looks right. Theres very little whit so theres a bunch of really dark low sat blue and it just doesnt match the bright pink. dunno, maybe im doing it wrong

 

not bad but its way way to bright i think . thas all i can say darken it mmaybe graident map or sumting reduce the whiteness and it wll look alot beter

 

well i darkened it and tried something different for the border. how is it now?

 

bump