The red grains look a bit bad on it in my opinion. I like v1 more. The depth is very good and I liked the concept, altough it seems a tad empty. The flow is preety good as well. Overall I think it is more then decent. I give it an 8.
wow the last three kick ass...definitely hot depth! the crysis one is my personal fave. i love that b/w style and the lighting fits very nice with the bg! nice job! wish i could do so too...
DraveN's render + great designing skills = WIN. Awesome formula that is. Nice work. Also like the other two. The best is the first one.
You really improved dude,lol. The last one looks like it needs some text imo, but it's still cool without. Coloring the 2nd one would ruin the effect in a way, I'd leave it b/w.