Dude, the second one by far but I think there are things you could improve on, like: ■ The text doesnt fit at all. And since where you have it is kind of the only spot to put any text, I would leave it out all together ■ Its nice smudging but I think you may have over done it just a little ■ There is a lot of neg space to the right which makes the sig feel empty ■ Theres not alot of detail to the bg at all. That also contributes to the empty feeling I dunno man, just looks kinda plain atm.
overall it's too light, but it's not really that bad in the colored version not sure about your lighting though
nic i love the coloured version they look so much better and bring the effects out aswell, the text goes well too, however it could be a lil bigger i tink nice work.
The colouring in the third version is great. I liked this one. The above posters said it all. I give it a 7.5/10.
wow. love it. one of the best tags ive seen in a while. love the way he is couloured and the bg isnt, very nice
I like it, but I think it's too bright. Maybe burn some of the render. ^_^ Also, the lighting is all over the place. here's what I do - I look at a render's natural lighting, then I try to play on that in my tag. It's fun. It also looks better than trying to force lighting. ^_^ Keep it up though, those aren't half bad.
I like the 4th one, but the text looks like you cut it out of the second one rather than copying the text layers.
