Which Is Better.

Okay GR, Rate this for me please.
I made this sig with this Pikachu render. (Got it from Planet Renders. Rendered by Xion_Glydus)

I have 2 versions.


This one is just a rectangle sig. (I'm using it right now.)


This one has Pikachu coming out of the sig, But he isn't actually finished off.
You can see that he has sort of an invisible box. I'm impartial to it but it kinda bugs me.

Can you please rate them? The one with a better rating I'll use.

Thanks guys~ ^_^

 

Render extensions in sigs are tacky IMO. As it always means the sig has poor blending.

 

v2, more graphical.

 

V1 like it.
I agree with Inverse 150%.
Pop outs are no good mate.

It could use a bit more blendage imo.
But the flow is ok. I like how you used
the lines to kind of give it a certain look.

Except for blending,
it's not bad.

Keep it up.

 

Alright, Thanks guys.
I'll stick with the one I have now.
Look out for more by me. Because it's coming ^_^

 

I agree with inverse, the extension sig looks tacky.

 

lawl pikachu

 

What's wrong with Pikachu? He's cute. >.>