Not very good smudging. Very simple. But I made everything besides the renders!! For the record, I have no idea what a topaz is, so if you think I used one, you're wrong Strom Trooper JayZ yay Mezzy! Hard criticism besides "Too simple." "not enough effects" "just plain sucks" Get specific, down to the core.
You just need practice honestly, everyone's first sigs look like these. Try using a less grungy brush for smudging. Also, try playing with the sharpen and blur tools when smudging. Try making the render more of a focus, putting it on the side detracts from the sig.
These arent me first sigs I've been photoshopping for like 2 years >.< Do they really look that sh*it*t*y???