5 6 5 Your effects are good, just need to be better implemented. Think about your composition. Nice text on the newest.
7 6- Seems a bit faded. Nice work though. I shudder to think what will be said of mine. Haha. I'm a newb to Photoshop.
3/10 Don't Really like the Boxy effect, need work on lighting, too monotone, and text needs a little work.