4/10 - Not a fan of the "lighten" effect and lacks depth. 6/10 - Great flow, could use work on coloring.
3- Not up to your standards >.> I don't like it at all. No identifiable lighting though i guess its to the left of his head, blending is bad, Text seems corny >.>. I think you used to many C4ds. The depth is ok. 8- Very good sig i like this one A LOT better EDIT: That was to Mattf >.> TO AG: i give it 6/10, i think it could of been better with color, not fan of B/W :tongue:
Middle one - Good lighting effects, but overdone IMO. Needs better-defined focal. Also the monsters(?) on the right just get cut off. 6.5-7 Already rated others.
7 -Nice flow, but I don't really get the lighting. All of the render's body is dark except some minor spots though it seems the light is covering all of the body (most). Text needs some work. Still really good sig though.