Rate The Sig Above You ..

@kalli

8/10

I actually really like this sig, the effects and concept are great and the b/w fits perfectly.

The only thing that brings it down imo is that at a first glance it dont make you want to look back at it and its only when you look at the sig you realise how good it is.

--------------

Rate my newest as well please as my current isnt one of my better sigs I just like wearing it.

Thanks

 

7/10 nice style don't like the full white boarder =\ nj though

 

9-FMA one

8

8

9

 

6

 

4 to bright render seems distorted seems blurry, not ezy on the eye
3 same thing as the first just the line made it worse

 

7
6
6
9
great job

 

Doom:
6 too bright and lacks foreground effects.
5 pretty basic and gaussian blur+lighten isn't good anymore.

Please rate this too:

 

5
5
5

Nothing bad, just nothing great.

 

4/10 - Work on colors, lighting and depth.
4/10 - Work on colors, lighting and depth.

Rate this:


~Ciel

 

7/10 light effects are pretty sweet and goes good with the background but its simple just not 10



rate please

 

wildirishman,

5/10 on all, you seen pretty basic atm, but it's not bad, it's just the way everyone starts, and you made some pretty good start if i see your wolverine tag! Just try to follow some tuts and create some hawt things and you'll be fine

 

8
6

 

7/10

8/10

I really like how the one on the bottem shines.

 

6 - A Blur+lighten sort of effect doesn't suit this piece IMO.


6.5 - Pretty cool on the whole, but effects need better execution. Bg could be added too.

 

Great sig,
8