1st: It looks pretty good and the background matches with the render 9/10 2nd: I like this one alot, it has all the key fetures a sig should be looking for exept the light draws you away from the main part of the sig so a 9/10 overall 18/20 for both sigs very well done.
love the efects, but not a fan of text 9/10 to dark but still good 8/10 to sharp in spots but nice 9/10
6/10 Blending needs work, the render doesn't really fit the background IMO. 7/10 BG Seems a bit dull, text needs work too.