uh..dont really know what to do with this one. Looks like just some tree bark. 5/10 looks like text was added and thats it. please tell me if im wrong.
6,5,pleasant color scheme and light source 6/10 nice concept ,the compostion could be better the white part on the right annoys me for example
6/10 7.5/10 way to many sparkles,and the scanlines dont look the good, text could use a bit of work, and that style is pretty old but their decent tags
3/10 5/10 sorry bro, not really feeling them. Check out some tutorials though, you'll get better as you keep designing.
that's just amazing effects, lighting, colors, depth... it all matches up. probly one of my fav sigs ever, 10/10 nothing could be better in that sig