Eh, 4/10 for both, they really.. seem to not do it for me. First one Render sticks out to much. Second one.. seems like just a text with clipping mask. >.>
i'd say 7.5 ... The effects aren't really going with the flow and the text isn't really easy to read. But the lightning and colors are fine and the choice of the stock is nice so ya, 7.5 ^^
1st Sig = Nice Lighting, Nice composition and I like it I will give it a 6/10, I may be great in simplicity but theres just not much happening. 2nd Sig = The background is ownzerz, I mean it freakin' rocks. I just dont like the way the stock blends in with the background at the bottom. 7/10
4/10 3/10 3/10 3/10 The first is your best, but nothing great. The second the lighting is like...ouchies! Then the last two are kinda just boring and the effects are too much over the renders.
Already rated those sigs, but that avatar. Oh god, that avatar. 10. Ok, sorry. Next rater can do Majin.
1. 8/10 2. 7/10 (Don't like much, mainly background spoilz in contract with the render, great colours )