I prefer the old one, hands down. Sure, it was whored, but who says that unique is always better? (Well, a lot of you lot lol, but still..)
Old one, easily. The old one had better buttons and text, plus this one is too dark and the left side (avatar, title, posts, reputation, wealth statis etc) looks soo much better on the old skin.
I think this one is better but the black should be lightened a lil...Im getting blind just by typing this
The new skin is good and all, But it needs shading. I literally can tell where the text box is in the quick reply. Its like that for any field. It just needs a little bit of shading then i would like the new skin ALOT!