I kno i dont give super high rates but to be honest the sig needs alot of work imo, and thats all it is, my opinion. That second sig is better but you should lose that pixelated area next to his head its not appealing i dont think. I would rate it 6.5 becuase text is a bit better than in the first where it really takes away from the sig. But since i kno u think i underate ill just not rate you anymore ^_^... next person plz rate both me and Victorious.
4 - the render sticks out too much and hes head is all blend 3,5 - the yellow bushing looks not nice and it seems that it just red and black with red and yellow duts don't like text in no-one of them.