6/10- see to many sigs like this. also border doesnt fit it at all. blending is good and lighting is off by far. needs some creativity thats all. decent sig though.
7.5/10 - i don't like the b/w on red and the overall effects on this one 9/10 - i just love the white squares efefcts and the text, the bg works completely fine with it all 8/10 - the bg and foreground dn't really fit togheter and the small details put in don't really go with it all, but it's pretty nice after all
3/10 for all, sorry. They all lack pretty much everything, as you are clearly new, i would try reading up on some tuts to learn some new techniques. May seem harsh to you, but better to be onest.