+1 midnight why: colors are more appealing, and even though the text on both is bad, midnight's is better.
R3 gmv, nice flow and colours used, nice render. Midnight yours is very nice, although i dislike the text. Good luck to you both.
Midnight. I like the lighting, the focus point, the text is ok, not bad or distracting. The other dude's is way too busy. R3=4 Midnight=3