1) Poor text, wierd border, and flat sig. 2/10 2) oversaturated render, same wierd line thingy around it, no depth 2/10 *rated 2 people above me, so i'll rate the dude right above me now. Ah well I think they're really nice sigs. Both could use maybe a bit more depth, but I like the style and layout on both. 8.5/10 on both sounds about right.
johndapunk 5/10 for both. kinda messy, and they need some more contrast The-Messiah 4/10 me c4d no no