The render could be blended in better, or a better render could've been chosen... it just doesn't seem to match the background for some reason. The backrgound, and effects themselves are good, though. 6/10
Bckground could have some work, its a tad bright and text is hard to read (the quote bit). 6/10 (I rated the top one)
1st one: the renders are blended ok, but i dont like the bg, at all. the quote is a bit hard to read. and your name doesnt really look good either. 4.5/10 2nd one: once again, the render is blended well, but the bg isnt attractive to me, at all, its kinda plain. the dodged(?) streaks are kinda..meh.. they just dont look good. the dots along with the text dont really match either. 5/10 oops: i guess we both wrote replies at same time. i was doing shawty's.
Ah, I want mine rated I think your background could maybe do with a bit of work but i like the effect on the arrow head and to the top right. You might not want to, but try using some C4D.
the first has a good render but im not feelin the bg 7.5/10 the second has real good blending and lighting it could use some darkness tho to make the light stand out more.8/10
1. 8.5/10 oversharpened 2. 7/10 it is much too colorful and the soft brushes over the render dont work 3. 6/10 light and bg arent very good
no borders 7... dont like the quick transition to pure black on the right, could have had a smooth gradient finish that side off imo. 6.5. text is meh. lighting is good.
I really like the upper one, good blending and background, second one isn't great, background is simple and too contrasted 7,5/10 6/10
1st is again over sharpended and the 2nd is a bit bright and a little over contrasted but my 2nd fav from u
