1st is a 7/10 i like that one pretty good. 2nd is about a 5/10 dont like it but thats just me its fine for that styel
6/10 - Add a curves layer for some contrast 7/10 - Great flame effect 7/10 - Work on the coloring just a touch
8/10 like the BG 8/10 like how you made it look like a painting and all GJ and um on my 1st sig that is a sepia effect its not supposed to have THAT much color to it.. just a bit in places and not much contrast either its the way its supposed to be