Comashop Vs. Casey

First to 5 wins, Casey isn't registered here so don't ask.

Comashop

(Lighting's screwed I know)

Casey

 

I have to say that I like Casey's better. It has my vote. The colors appear to match smoothly.

 

Casey gmv. his fits with the background and looks more appealing. the think that ruined it for the other is the white in the corner

 

Both had a very decent atmosphere, but Casey gets my vote for two reasons:

The render is better contrasted.
The background is a little pixelated in Comashop's.

 

casey gmv..

don like the brightness of the other sig.. text is too bright..

 

Voting Comashop. The lightsource was well-positioned and the text is exempliary. One can tell a great deal of thought went into it, right down to the border.

 

Comashop gmv. The other render really doesnt seem to fit with the background, and i like the lighting in the first one

 

Comashop gmv - lightning isn't that bad =p
Though Casey's are good, I like the "calmer" style of the first.

 

Im turning it around 4:3 in favor of Casey

 

Comashop gmv

 

4:4 now, should have made it win by 2 but meh.

 

i vote casey.

his sig is nice it has good flow and well comashops looks kind of screwey and i dont like the lighting

 

i vote casey its blended more overall better and the first one is too light

 

I like Comashop's better.

Casey's seem more edgey in my opinion