Forum Idea

Totally agreed...

every word of it also, UV and T3 stuff isnt too good to me. Yet they are the "pro's"
No offence to them at all, I personally cant do any better probly, but i just dont like em really..

and you KNOW some idiots will take beginner/inter stages the wrong way and start flaming

also, it'll just be about trends. Let people decide what they should pay for a signature themself. not what other people rate it as. It's that simple...

 

I only read the first post of this, so i'm only going to reply to that.

The words "pro" or "intermediate" are subjective. To veterans of this site they might seem easy to make, or newbie, but to newcomer to photoshop they really might seem pro or so on... Then you get to freedom of speech, which i guess it freedom of text on forums , the people that made the art are free to name it what they wish, unless a forum is considered private property and thus can be silenced by an admin with powers to do so. This is my 'overall opinion', but seriously my personal opinion is that if you see someone with a post like that, check it out, if it's good, then be interested, if not, call them noobie in the privacy of your own home, but I think that making a commitee that rates siges based on their own opinon or guidelines so that when they're selling the sigs......blah blah blah skip skip skip...is overkill.

 

oh yea...






we dont want this place to turn into a NSL now do we...

 

NSL? I only know SNL.

 

its the national sig league, its a website where you can go and get rated by self-nominated "pros" basically...

 

I hate the word pro actully. I just like going through the auction room and seeing a sig that I thinks great, and bidding on it.

 

pretty nice idea dude

 

i htinks its a nice idea, but i thnik we would have to vote to see who can be considered pro.

but i dont think people will be able too see more than just the face of a sig

 

pro/inter/novice=whatever
its all about personal taste if they wanna call it pro let them you dont have to buy it .....
like what everyone said its all about personal taste

1)they may consider Their signature they are selling pro hence why they called it pro
2) in your eyes it maybe novice
3)in someone elses they see pro

so at the end of the day does it really matter people arent forcing you to buy the tag / signature

i tell you one thing that annoys me the most is when ........
someone goes in to there thread and says OMG WTFBBQ thats not pro thats not worth 600 credits i wouldnt buy that ...
thats just being out right rude and flaming there thread
1)they arent asking you to buy it
2)theres no need for it
3)if you dont like it leave the thread alone its there thread and thats just being disrespectful if you go on in and start flaming them for wanting to earn some credits

/end rant :wub:

also just to set the record straight on the uv and t3 crews only doing sigs thats FALSE a LOT if not all of the members do large art me included i only do large art

 

Gurly I agree with everything u said I just wanna add that if you don't like the signature of someone u can post ur opinion, but to give positive critics to help others... They only thing that can possibly happens is the other person doesn't agree with u... and u gotta respect that cause art is very subjective and can't be qualified as good or bad...

 

if you want your sig to be rated
go and ask in your stuff..no need for a new section

btw i dont like sig ratings..cuz yeah everyone's opinion is different
just replying to the first post

 

Basically Gurly said what I said, just in less words lmao

And yes, I know UV and T3 arent only signatures, but they do focus on them because they are GR crews and signatures are more of a thing at GR than LPs. I talk to people from both crews and get along with both of them actually lmao...

But yeah, the novice/inter/pro ratings mean nothing. As everyone else in the thread except a few people have been saying, its all opinionated. What I may consider pro, someone may consider inter or novice, etc.

 

good statement, which is why I like the idea now of filtering the words pro. It would work better for everyone. People don't get flamed at, the people make more creds because there is no one flaming them and putting their tut or psd down.

 

good...no need to know what NSL now....