There both not very good but CWD gets my vote for the good render and brushing. Shredaa i liked yours but its to plan and you should of left the redner at its oringal color
I really don't like the popout sigs but if I voted for one of them it would be the first one. The second just looks strange to me.
Yeppers I have to vote for Shredaa simpley because his is great and I don't see any flaws in it the coloring is great... As far as for the render color I like it I think making it all the same color was good. Now it matchs the BG Dhoo!!! CDW'S is ok but the blending is poor on it the render was ither blended to much or the opc. was turn to low on it because you can see threw the render it self and thats not good on a pop out siggy.. In all it looks like it was just trough-n together... Vote:Shredaa Reason: ^^ Score:3-2
this was a real tuff choice for me. both sigs were really good, but also had some flaws imo shredaa - very ncie. nice use of render. like the font but it doesnt go well imo with the rest. colros are right on! also, its a little plain fo rmy liking CWD - the render is almost see thru, as previously mentioned, thats not good in a popout. i like ho the text is out of bounds. and you used up all your space. i like that. so i vote for CWD score 3-3
allright, ill be expecting my creds soon. Tyhanx For Battling and u have a nice sig. Thanx Voters for voting fairly and voting for me sig ( meaning u like )
CWD. @Shredaa: I would've made the bottom the dirt color you had it then transition it to its normal mode, like its been running through mud.
