4/10 da what??? uv like... got no bg... and the cloudy white stuffs ruin the girl... ew 8/10 COLOUR and BG. very good.
overall 7.8/1i like the first one but it's a bit too bright and plain, try adding some effcts. (check the tut in my sig) the first one is too newbie, downloaded brushing non'matching BG.
...2/10 like wtf. hurts my eyes dude. your colours are clashing. try using two maybe three colours total in a sig and mae them similiar... 8/10 nice bg and use of the picture. the text is well done and its a nice overal sig. only problem is the bottem border seems to be thicker than on the other three sides???