Rate The Sig Above You ..

First one: 8/10

Cool designs and effects, too much empty space on the left for me though.

Second: 7/10

I liek the idea, but ti woudl be better without the light on Gollum's head, and I can't make out any of the text.

Rate both of mine please.

 

5/10
6.5/10

The text kills it and it needs a bit more blending

 

Nice work on all 3

1st one is 8.5/10, it feels too bright for mw

2nd one is 9/10 I like how all the colors flow nicely

3rd one is 9.5/10 love the render and love the work on the sig

 

7.5/10
6/10

 

Interesting.......8/10.

 

6/10. Move the text out of the corner, and it could do with a bit of depth.

 

Personnally it's too blah for me, so that's going to effect my rating, but, I like where the majority of the lighting is, and to me it has an either sandy, or cosmic look to it.

7/10.

 

hmm all a bit to chaotic with colors and effects.
text needs some work to.
6/10 all arround

 

8.5/10

 

Pretty cool stuff. 8/10.

 

6/10

 

6.5/10
7.5/10

 

8/10
9/10
6/10

 

I like the first one but the second is hard for me to tell its a flower.
8/10
710

 

both look nice

8/10 overall