7/10. i actually quite like the first one except that it's so compressed. try to expand it a bit. second one is the same thing.
........ wow. we need to sticky that. "no borders..." sig doesn't need borders man. but it's your taste, i'm cool with it. 5.5/10 for first. decent coloring, but no flow of the sig. 4.5/10 for second. the text just does not work. at all.
ye, i tried to make it look like batman flying forward, with c4d streaking from the ball of light. but ps decided to be gay. 6.5/10. that would look soo cool if you enlarged the energy ball inside his gun.
7/10, The BG flows very well with the render and the colors fit in perfectly, but it seems like something is missing..