well looks like mack just brushed the background a bit added a render and a colour layer. very plain umm black label i dont like the lines across it but i still like ur sig so u get my vote urs wasnt plain and well blended 3-1 black
While I agree that Mack's sig is plain it is well composed and does have some brushing (although it does need more). Black's sig seems to lack direction (literally). The render is going one way, the scanlines are going another and then those ghost bars are going in yet ANOTHER direction. Too many angles. Also, I htink the text needs work (font change). 3-2 black leading
going for black label.. I dont lilke the other one's color , it just has no feeling and emotion to it.. Where as black's is blended properly and has smooth colors
ill go with blacklabel. i really like how he did it overall, it kinda looks to me like theres some energy stuff rushing upwards. mack, i really like yours too, but BL's stood out. also, did you make that render? cuz i thought i saw a brush set like that once. 5-4 blacklabel
dude...mack, sorry i just got here. i was gonna vote for you, your entry should of pwned, bro. i dont know what happened, but you got ripped off! some peeps just voting for their friends, or something...