Dovesink V.s Skula

Dovesink


Skula


1st to 5 votes wins.

 

close one but im going to have to vote for dovensink because his text rocks and is a nice sig skullas i dont like the
pixel strecth our the red lines w.e it is but both r nice sigs

 

I don't really like any of them that much.
Skula: Your sig is almost as much white as red, and it simply looks plain wierd. There's nothing I really like about it, except the text.
Dovesink: Your sig ain't that good either. Very simple, the boarder is cut out to the right, and the text ain't that good either.
I have to go with Dovesink.

 

I'm going to go with Skula, Like the blending of the render and the text isn't too bad either. With Dovesink, I like the BG really good, but the text isn't that appealing to me and niether is the blending effect of the render.

 

I say dove sink. I like how he built it up off the render with the colours and the text.

Dove Sink GMV.

 

3-1. Thanks much for voting guys. I'll consider the comments and will adjust in other sigs if it is a really big problem

 

Dovesink gets my vote.

Both need a lot of work, but his is better overall.

 

I don't like either, to be honest Both are really basic.

DoveSink: The border doesn't show on the right, I think the size is too large and it's just kind of plain.

Skula: Pixel stretches are whored Text is alright though.

Skula GMV.

 

Dovesink because the other sigs pixel stretch isnt that good.

 

5-2.

Yea, I know the border on right is cut off but I did that to experiment. To me it kinda looks better couse that border is used alot with other people. I don't know about too large tho... I almost never put in more then 1 signature so its great size for me. Some people put in up to 8 :lol:

Anyways I've had to edit this post because I counted wrong. It seems like its 5-2 and not 4-2, maybe somebody who voted made a change of heart or I just made a mistake.

 

I have never liked pixel stretch sigs and I think that this one looks distored for some reason.

Dovesink GMV, although I don't like the right side of the border missing.

 

Hmm, Skula Gots my vote. because i like the style, text and the way the sig is made.

 

Ok, first off, I think they are both terrible. That out of the way, Skula gets my vote for this battle. I like to colors better, and the text, compared to Dovesink. And Dovesink is missing some border on his sig.

 

Why are they horrible?

 

Skula gmv, I actually quite like it, not the best sig I've ever seen but definitely not bad. I liek the way the background works, something a bit different. dove has too much empty space for my tastes.