The BG and the smudge effect are great, I also love the light play of the BG and the render. Kind of goes from light on the BG side to dark with the shadow render. The onlything that I don't like is the text, that is by far the weakest part of your sig. 8.9/10
overall im really not digging your sigs, imo you need a lot of work on all aspects keep trying ^^ 4/10 overall
well those lines pretty much the - thing in the sig. and it looks a bit monoton.e add more contrast. but bg looks nice. 7/10